top of page
  • Writer's pictureSam Orlando

State of Separation: A Look into America's Growing Secessionist Sentiments

Written by: Sam Orlando

New research reveals a growing inclination toward state secession, pointing to deep state and partisan divisions as major contributing factors.

Understanding Secession Sentiments

Recent statements from Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.) on September 11, advocating for state secession, have stirred conversations and placed focus on the sentiments and rationale behind the secessionist inclinations of approximately one-fifth of Americans. Greene attributed her call for secession to what she perceives as President Biden’s lack of response to border issues.

State Division as a Crucial Factor

However, a deeper exploration reveals it might not be merely dissatisfaction with federal governance driving these notions but perceived meaningful differences between states. Nicholas F. Jacobs, an assistant professor from Colby College, highlighted the division between states as a crucial element in support for secession. Jacobs asserts that perceived substantial differences in the quality of government services among states are pivotal in fostering divisive sentiments.

Partisan Agreement on Secession

Jacobs’s research indicates that 20 to 30 percent of partisans from both major parties express some level of agreement with secessionist sentiments, even in the absence of a major secessionist party or movement. Approximately 18 percent of respondents in his study agreed with all three proposals related to secession.

Growing Concerns over State-Based Rights

A study by the Pew Research Center echoed Jacobs’s findings, showing heightened concerns among Americans, especially Democrats, over the variability of rights based on the state of residence, likely impacted by the altering access to abortion and differing state governance.

The Feasibility of Secession

Jacobs clarified that the unfolding secessionist sentiments might not necessarily lead to violent conflicts but emphasized the pressing need to examine the evolving perceptions of division within the United States. He also noted the inherent diversity within states, indicating that the divides are not just inter-state but also intra-state, challenging the practicality of secession as a solution to perceived problems.

Conclusion: Remembering the Past

It is imperative to remember that the United States literally went into a Civil War over secession, underscoring the gravitas of such divisive notions. This historic event accentuates the importance of addressing and understanding the underlying issues and perceptions leading to such sentiments in contemporary times. The significance of vigilance and conscientious dialogue among Americans cannot be overstated, especially in times marked by uncertainty and heightened political polarization. The discourse initiated by figures like Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene necessitates a deeper exploration of the intricate dynamics propelling secessionist sentiments among Americans, calling for a balanced and informed conversation to foster national unity and resolve underlying tensions.

16 views0 comments


bottom of page