top of page
  • Writer's pictureSam Orlando

Kentucky Representative's Incest Law Amendment Stirs Controversy and Debate

Nick Wilson's Legislative Proposal to Amend Incest Laws and Address Parole for Violent Offenders Sparks Debate and Criticism

Written by: Bonnie Chapman

In a move that has ignited both controversy and conversation, Kentucky Republican Nick Wilson recently introduced House Bill 269, aiming to amend the state's existing incest laws. The bill initially sought to exclude "first cousin" from the list of familial relationships deemed unlawful for sexual relations. The proposal, introduced to the House Committee on Committees on January 16, was swiftly withdrawn and refiled by Wilson, citing a drafting error that mistakenly retained the reference to "first cousin."

Legislative Process

The bill's journey through the legislative corridors was marked by rapid developments. Shortly after its initial introduction, Wilson acknowledged a drafting oversight, leading to the bill's withdrawal and subsequent refiling. This correction, made within a 24-hour window, aimed to rectify the unintended inclusion of "first cousin" in the definition of incest.

Background on Nick Wilson

Nick Wilson, a figure known both in the courtroom and on the reality TV stage, has charted an unconventional path to political prominence. A public defender by profession, Wilson first captured national attention as the winner of "Survivor: David vs. Goliath" in 2018 and later appeared on the show's 40th season in 2020. Riding the wave of his reality TV fame, Wilson ventured into politics, running unopposed for the 82nd District of the Kentucky House in November 2022.

Kentucky Incest Law

The current incest law in Kentucky categorizes sexual relations with certain relatives, including first cousins, as unlawful. Wilson's proposed amendment initially aimed to recalibrate this definition, sparking a debate over familial relationships and legal boundaries. While the bill's intention was quickly clarified and corrected, the proposal shed light on the complexities and sensitivities surrounding incest legislation.

Parole for Violent Offenders

Beyond the controversy over familial relationships, House Bill 269 also delved into the legal treatment of violent offenders convicted of incest. The bill proposed broadening the definition of incest to include "sexual contact," thereby expanding the legal scope and addressing nuances in incest cases. This aspect of the bill underscores a concerted effort to refine and fortify legal provisions related to familial abuse.

Wilson's Statement on Mistake

In the wake of the drafting mishap, Wilson came forward to acknowledge the error and affirm his commitment to correcting it. He emphasized the bill's overarching goal of combating familial abuse and stressed the importance of maintaining "first cousin" within the legal framework of incest. Expressing confidence in the legislative system's ability to address and rectify such errors, Wilson's response aimed to reaffirm the bill's intentions and his dedication to legislative integrity.

Response and Criticism

The bill, however, has not been without its critics. Notably, Eliza Orlins, a fellow Survivor alumnus and New York public defender, voiced her concerns via a TikTok video, branding Wilson's bill as "truly insane." Orlins's critique extends beyond the bill itself, questioning Wilson's utilization of his Survivor fame in the political arena and highlighting broader legislative priorities amidst the myriad challenges facing Kentucky. This publicized criticism adds a layer of complexity to the ongoing discourse surrounding the proposed legislative changes.

As House Bill 269 continues to navigate the tumultuous waters of public opinion and legislative scrutiny, its journey underscores the intricate interplay between personal backgrounds, legislative endeavors, and societal perceptions in the realm of political discourse.

11 views0 comments


bottom of page