top of page
  • Writer's pictureSam Orlando

From Murder to Mandamus: Exposing Augusta County's Web of Lies and Illicit Affairs

Written by: Michael Phillips

Breaking Through News Sues Augusta County for Another FOIA Violation

AUGUSTA COUNTY, VIRGINIA - In Augusta County, Virginia, a tale of legal battles, alleged law enforcement misconduct, and a push for transparency unfolds, revealing a complex web of relationships, secrecy, and a community's quest for answers. At the heart of this narrative is Breaking Through Media, LLC, and its editor, Samuel Joseph Orlando, who have initiated legal action against Augusta County Sheriff Donald Smith under the Virginia Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). This lawsuit seeks to shed light on the shadows cast by undisclosed relationships within the sheriff's office, particularly in the tragic case of Khaleesi Cuthriell.

The saga began with the sentencing of Candi Royer and Travis Brown, marking the end of a legal chapter that deeply impacted the community but also amplified questions regarding the transparency of local law enforcement. Revelations about an alleged affair between Royer and Deputy Dylan Johnson, and claims that Johnson was aware of Khaleesi's whereabouts, thrust the sheriff's office into controversy. Travis Brown's exclusive interview with Breaking Through News, revealing insights into the relationship between Royer and Johnson, added layers of complexity and concern, suggesting a conflict of interest and a troubling lack of oversight within the sheriff's department.

This backdrop of legal and ethical turmoil sets the stage for Breaking Through News' legal confrontation with Sheriff Smith. The media outlet's pursuit of public records through FOIA requests aims to uncover the extent of law enforcement's knowledge and actions in the case of Khaleesi Cuthriell. Despite submitting detailed requests for communications and records related to Royer, Johnson, Brown, and Khaleesi from January 1, 2020, to the present, Breaking Through News faced delays and obstructions. Responses from the sheriff's office, indicating additional time and costs for compliance, have highlighted the challenges faced by journalists and citizens in accessing public information, prompting Breaking Through News to take legal action.

Legal and Ethical Concerns

The allegations of an affair between Royer and Deputy Johnson not only raise questions about personal misconduct but also point to potential breaches of ethical standards within law enforcement. Such relationships can compromise the integrity of investigations and erode public trust in the police force. The legal action by Breaking Through News seeks not only to access withheld information but also to highlight the need for clear ethical guidelines and accountability mechanisms within law enforcement agencies.

Historical and Systemic Challenges

The struggle for transparency in Augusta County is reflective of broader, systemic challenges faced by those seeking to hold public officials accountable through FOIA requests. Across the nation, journalists and citizens encounter similar obstacles, from bureaucratic delays to excessive fees, underscoring the ongoing battle for open government. This case exemplifies the critical role of the press in confronting these barriers and advocating for the public's right to information.

Potential Impact and Implications

The outcome of Breaking Through News' lawsuit against Sheriff Smith could have far-reaching implications for transparency and accountability in law enforcement. A victory for the media outlet would not only set a precedent for FOIA compliance but also signal to public agencies the importance of ethical conduct and open communication. Moreover, it would underscore the judiciary's role in upholding citizens' rights to government information, reinforcing the foundation of a democratic society where public officials are answerable to the people they serve.

Samuel Orlando's statement encapsulates the central theme of this unfolding story: the fundamental right to transparency and the legal obligation of public officials to adhere to FOIA laws. "The Augusta County Sheriff is simply not above the law. He does not get to choose which statutes he follows and which ones he breaks," Orlando asserts. "It is sad that a media outlet has to sue a law enforcement executive to follow the law, but such is the state of government in Augusta County today. Breaking Through News will fight for this public access, and we are confident that we will prevail."

This legal battle against the backdrop of a high-profile murder case underscores a broader narrative about the importance of transparency, accountability, and the public's right to know. The efforts of Breaking Through News to enforce FOIA requests not only aim to bring closure and clarity to the community reeling from a tragic loss but also serve as a testament to the crucial role of the press in upholding democratic values. As this case progresses, it will undoubtedly raise questions about the integrity of law enforcement practices, the potential conflicts of interest, and the imperative for systemic reform.

The legal action by Breaking Through News symbolizes a stand against opacity in government and law enforcement, embodying the pursuit of truth and justice in the face of adversity. As the community awaits the outcomes of this lawsuit, the story of Augusta County, with its interwoven themes of tragedy, alleged misconduct, and the fight for openness, will resonate far beyond its borders, highlighting the enduring importance of transparency in fostering trust and accountability in public institutions.


bottom of page