top of page
  • Writer's pictureSam Orlando

Caught on Camera: How Citizen Oversight is Challenging Corruption in the Augusta Sheriff's Office

Written by: Ismael Barrios and Sam Orlando

Augusta County Deputy Convicted of Beating Two People Recording Him at a Traffic Stop

STAUNTON, VIRGINIA - In the picturesque Shenandoah Valley of Virginia, the importance of recording police interactions has come sharply into focus. The recent convictions and charges against deputies in the Augusta County Sheriff's Office underscore the critical role that video evidence plays in law enforcement accountability. This need becomes even more pressing when viewed against the backdrop of a department mired in controversy under the leadership of Sheriff Donald Smith.

The Catalysts: Cases of Taylor and Mikolay

The conviction of Deputy CJ Taylor on assault charges and the serious allegations against Sgt. William Mikolay have brought the issue of police accountability to the forefront. In Taylor's case, video evidence provided by bystanders was instrumental, highlighting the absence of official body cam footage. Mikolay's charges, including a felony for malicious wounding, further emphasize the gravity of the accusations against members of the sheriff's office.

A Decade of Controversy

These incidents are but the latest in a long line of controversies that have dogged Sheriff Smith's tenure. From the mishandling of evidence to associations with convicted human traffickers, the sheriff's office has faced repeated allegations of misconduct. The saga involving Smith's handling of his brother's legal troubles, covering up arrest warrants for his "close friend" Felix Chujoy, alleged witness tampering, and retaliation against whistleblowers paints a troubling picture of a law enforcement agency in crisis.

The Importance of Recording

In this context, the ability of citizens to record police interactions becomes a powerful tool for transparency and accountability. Video evidence can serve as an unbiased witness in legal proceedings, filling the gaps left by the lack of official body cam footage.

Legal Rights and Guidelines for Recording Police:

  1. Know Your Rights: In Virginia, as in many states, you are legally allowed to record police officers performing their duties in public spaces. This right is protected under the First Amendment, provided you do not interfere with their duties.

  2. Maintain a Safe Distance: While recording, ensure you are at a safe and respectful distance from any police activity. Interfering with police operations can lead to arrest and the potential for your footage to be dismissed in court.

  3. Announce Your Intent: It's advisable, though not legally required, to inform the officers that you are recording. This can help avoid misunderstandings and reinforce your non-interfering stance. If it is not practical to notify officers, consider calling the police department and notifying the dispatcher of your presence and the fact that you are engaging in a constitutional right to record the police.

  4. Understand the Importance: Video evidence can be crucial in court, offering an unbiased account of interactions. In the absence of body cam footage from Augusta County Sheriff's Deputies, citizen recordings can fill critical gaps in evidence.

  5. Use Technology Wisely: Modern smartphones have features that allow for quick access to camera functions. Familiarize yourself with these features and consider using apps designed to upload footage to cloud storage instantly, safeguarding against loss or deletion.

  6. Consider Forwarding Video for Preservation: If corrupt police get your phone, they may delete your video evidence. Consider sending the video immediately to a trusted third party, or password protect your phone so that officers on the scene won't be able to access your evidence against them.

  7. Stay Informed on Local Laws: While the right to record is generally protected, specific regulations can vary by locality. Stay informed about any local ordinances or state laws that might affect your right to record.

The Need for Systemic Reform

The unfolding narrative in Augusta County, from the Taylor and Mikolay cases to the broader history of allegations against the sheriff's office, underscores the urgent need for systemic reform. It highlights the necessity of body cams and robust oversight mechanisms to ensure law enforcement accountability.

A Community's Quest for Transparency and Justice

As the community grapples with these challenges, the role of citizens in documenting police interactions has never been more vital. The courage to record, coupled with the push for transparency and reform, stands as a beacon of hope for restoring trust between law enforcement and the people they serve.

The saga of the Augusta County Sheriff's Office serves as a stark reminder of the power of video evidence and the critical role it plays in the pursuit of justice. As the department moves forward, the community remains watchful, hopeful for a future where accountability is not the exception but the norm.


bottom of page