top of page
  • Writer's pictureSam Orlando

Augusta County Sheriff Hid Brother's Chase from Staunton PD: The Story of the Sheriff's Brother's Multiple Arrests

Written by: Sam Orlando

A Scandal Deepens in Virginia's Shenandoah Valley

STAUNTON, VIRGINIA - Nestled in the Shenandoah Valley of Virginia, Augusta County is known for its picturesque landscapes and historic sites. As a community steeped in tradition and Southern charm, it often finds itself at a crossroads of preserving its agricultural heritage and navigating the complexities of modern-day challenges. This backdrop sets the stage for the unfolding drama involving one of its own, Ronald William Smith, and the local law enforcement's handling of his case.

A Troubled Past Emerges - Layers of Controversy

Ronald Smith is Augusta County Sheriff Donald Smith's twin brother. The narrative of Ronald Smith in Augusta County is a complex tapestry of legal entanglements and familial connections. His troubled past with the law, especially his implication in a fraudulent inmate call scheme and drug convictions in 2015, suggests a pattern of controversial actions. In the fraudulent call scheme, Ronald Smith used other inmate's pin numbers to call his brother, Sheriff Donald Smith. The Sheriff accepted some of those calls from other inmate's pins, which as a law enforcement officer means he knew those other inmates were being forced to pay for his phone calls with his brother.

The involvement of his brother, Sheriff Donald Smith, in these matters adds a layer of complexity, raising questions about the intertwining of personal ties and professional responsibilities.

The October Arrest - A Bond and Brotherhood Tested

In October of 2023, just two months before the high-profile chase that claimed recent local headlines, Ronald's encounter with the law in Staunton—a tranquil city located within Augusta County—led to charges of felony drug possession, DUI, and obstructing justice. His bail was set at $2,200, and he was released by the Court in Staunton after posting his bail with a bail bondsman. This incident and Ronald’s subsequent release on bond were the precursors to the dramatic pursuit led by his twin brother, Sheriff Donald Smith.

The December Chase: A Law Enforcement Paradox

On December 26, Sheriff Smith reports that he notified his deputies of his attempt to stop his brother, who he claimed had absconded with his truck. Deputies then engaged in a chase, attempting a stop in the City of Staunton, but - according to Staunton Police Sgt. Butch Williams, Augusta never notified Staunton of the emergency, the chase, or the fact that they had a fleeing fugitive, on Staunton City charges, who had stolen a vehicle associated with a law enforcement officer. The high-speed chase in December, led by Sheriff Donald Smith, highlighted a law enforcement paradox. Despite Ronald’s active bond in Staunton and his legal status being known to his brother, the Staunton Police Department was kept in the dark about the pursuit within their jurisdiction. This failure to communicate by the Sheriff's Office raises serious questions about the balance between familial loyalty and public responsibility.

A Chase Through Staunton - The Silent Sirens

The pursuit took an alarming turn as it entered Staunton, with a critical moment near Highway 262 and Commerce Road. The absence of communication from the Sheriff's Office to the Staunton PD, particularly during a high-stakes chase, signifies a worrying lapse in inter-agency cooperation. This oversight becomes more critical considering Ronald was out on bond for charges in Staunton, yet the local police were not involved in the pursuit.

Implications and Unanswered Questions

This incident highlights significant questions about law enforcement practices and inter-agency communication, especially in high-risk situations. The fact that the pursuit was managed solely by the Augusta County Sheriff's Office until reaching Verona without involving other departments is a concerning gap in law enforcement cooperation. These issues necessitate a closer examination of the protocols and decision-making processes in such scenarios.

Charting a New Course in Augusta County

The events surrounding Ronald Smith have brought to light the need for systemic reform within Augusta County's law enforcement framework. This case underscores the importance of seamless inter-agency cooperation and clear communication for public safety. As investigations continue, there is a growing expectation for transparency and accountability, with the hope that this incident will lead to meaningful changes in law enforcement operations, ensuring the safety and well-being of the community.

66 views0 comments
bottom of page