top of page
  • Writer's pictureSam Orlando

Hallelujah or Bust? The Maryland Church of God That Took Its Insurance Company to Court

Because nothing says "divine love" like a two-million-dollar storm damage claim.

Written by Sam Orlando

WALDORF, MD - In the quaint town of Waldorf, Maryland, the New Hope Church of God is a pillar of the community, offering solace, charity, and good old-fashioned spirituality. Yet recently, the Church was hit by a storm so ungodly, it's compelling them to find shelter in the courts.

It appears the heavens opened up with something other than blessings, leaving the sanctuary damaged to the tune of more than $2 million. "But worry not," thought the congregation, "for we are insured with the Brotherhood Mutual Insurance." The name alone exudes trust and solidarity, doesn't it? Turns out, not quite.

A Tale of Two Claims

Ahh, insurance claims—those labyrinthine realms where everyday people turn into amateur sleuths, case number in hand. The Church originally submitted a claim under number 608080. Brotherhood Mutual, as if mirroring the Church's divine nature of omnipresence, decided one claim wasn't enough and miraculously generated a second one—claim #0641666. Maybe they thought the Church needed a second blessing, or maybe the devil is really in the details.

Slow and Steady Doesn't Always Win the Race

With the agility of a tortoise on sedatives, the insurance company took over six months to initiate an inspection. And when it finally happened, they inspected only the mysterious second claim, effectively ignoring the original one. They say good things come to those who wait, but I'm not sure that applies to waiting for an insurance claim.

The Divine Comedy of "Good Faith"

Maryland law uses phrases like "good faith," describing it as "an informed judgment based on honesty and diligence." Ah, the irony! New Hope Church of God alleges that Brotherhood Mutual neither made informed judgments nor acted in good faith. I'm beginning to wonder if the 'brotherhood' in Brotherhood Mutual is more Cain and Abel than David and Jonathan.

Prayer for Relief

Not the kind you're thinking. The Church is asking for more than $2 million in damages, legal fees, and whatever else it takes to make them whole again. Perhaps this is the modern version of casting out demons; expelling bureaucratic inefficiencies and malevolence cloaked in contract fine print.

In a world where we look for signs from above for guidance, maybe the New Hope Church of God should have sought a divine second opinion before trusting their worldly assets to a mere mortal institution. But then again, isn't that what insurance is—a leap of faith?

For now, the Church, with its congregation and its lawyers, will head to court to fight their Goliath. If you're looking for a religious experience, you might just find it in a Maryland courtroom this year.

13 views0 comments


bottom of page